On May 24, 2014, Lost Creek residents went to a special meeting with Austin City Councilman Mike Martinez to talk about a 37-acre tract at the top of Lost Creek Boulevard. Cousins Properties had the land under contract. Its attorney, Steve Drenner, said the company planned to ask for a rezoning from single-family residential to a commercial planned unit development, Community Impact reported at the time. Residents raised traffic, the look of an office building in the neighborhood and the loss of open space.
Twelve years later, the land is being sold as houses. The Overlook at Westlake has 48 homesites on the former Marshall Ranch parcel, and MileStone Community Builders is the builder. A buyer comparing Westlake homes gets a rare thing here: a published price sheet for new construction inside a neighborhood that was built out decades ago. The sheet shows that the lot sets the price. Two homes on the same floor plan are listed more than half a million dollars apart.
Ten years of office proposals came before the houses
The 2014 proposal included multistory office buildings, one or two parking garages and possibly an assisted-living center. The Lost Creek Neighborhood Association raised concerns about building height and setbacks and pointed out that a cemetery on the tract would need protecting.
By August 2014 the concept had grown to two office buildings of five and seven stories plus a garage. A fire station, senior living or a day care was also floated for the site, Community Impact reported. Cousins later withdrew. In October 2015, owner Dan Marshall came back with a revised office plan, and the neighborhood association president called it less alarming, according to Community Impact. In December 2016 the tract sold to Riverside Resources, which had not committed to a plan. City zoning and platting records from 2021 show a residential subdivision moving forward under the existing SF-2 single-family zoning.
That history explains the price sheet. The land around Lost Creek was spoken for long ago. The neighborhood's planning started in 1972, and about 50 homes were standing when the association formed in 1976. Community Impact put it plainly in December 2025: "Land is scarce within the Eanes ISD." A 37-acre single-family parcel that survived ten years of office proposals is about as scarce as west Austin land gets. The builder's numbers show what buyers are paying for it.
Same plan, two prices, half a million apart
MileStone's community page for The Overlook lists seven plans with starting prices that run from $2,905,990 for the Pinnacle, at 3,326 to 3,393 square feet, to $3,748,990 for the Destin, at about 5,256 square feet. On the same page, in November 2026, the builder listed five available homes on specific homesites. Each one is priced well above its plan's starting figure.
| Address | Plan | Sq. ft. | Plan starts at | Listed price | Difference | Listed price per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1209 Eternity Terrace | Destin | 5,257 | $3,748,990 | $4,614,274 | $865,284 | about $878 |
| 1216 Eternity Terrace | Berkley | 4,937 | $3,440,990 | $4,717,046 | $1,276,056 | about $955 |
| 6205 Marshall Ranch Road | Summit | 4,937 | $3,725,990 | $4,905,740 | $1,179,750 | about $994 |
| 1113 Eternity Terrace | Destin | 5,256 | $3,748,990 | $5,146,729 | $1,397,739 | about $979 |
| 1117 Eternity Terrace | Summit | 5,025 | $3,725,990 | $5,259,189 | $1,533,199 | about $1,047 |
Compare the two Destins. They are the same plan and their square footage differs by one foot, yet 1113 Eternity Terrace is listed $532,455 above 1209 Eternity Terrace. The two Summits on the sheet are $353,449 apart. 1117 Eternity Terrace is the larger of the two by 88 square feet, which accounts for very little of that gap. On this street, the floor plan is the smaller part of the price and the homesite plus what goes on it is the larger part.
The builder's own description points to why. Lots run from a quarter acre to three-quarters of an acre. MileStone uses all-inclusive pricing, and every home can include a pool or enhanced landscaping, Community Impact reported. The same report says buyers can choose a flat lot with a view toward Omni Barton Creek Resort or toward downtown Austin. A threefold spread in lot size and two different views fit inside one gated street. On a hillside in 78746, those differences are what the extra half million buys.
The top of the sheet has moved past the first quote
In December 2025, MileStone sales executive Lily Otis gave Community Impact a range of $2.85 million to $5 million for the community. At that point 8 of the 48 homesites had sold, and sales were running from a trailer behind the model home at 1300 Lost Creek Blvd. Reservations had opened in May 2025, Tribeza reported.
Eleven months later, the bottom of the range has barely moved, with the Pinnacle starting at $2,905,990. The top has gone past it. Two of the five available homes are listed above $5 million, and the highest is $5,259,189 for the Summit at 1117 Eternity Terrace. Its estimated availability is November 2026. The Summit at 6205 Marshall Ranch Road is marked move-in ready. The other three carry estimated December 2026 availability. The page also says no homes are under construction at this time. So a buyer shopping this month is choosing among finished or nearly finished houses on specific lots.
Practical details on the community: it is gated, it sits inside the city of Austin and uses city services, and Kimley-Horn is a subcontractor on a planned $3 million water tower on the northeast side of the property.
What the October market adds to the comparison
The newest market figures are regional, and they set the background for any west Austin price conversation this fall. In October 2026, Austin metro homes that sold spent an average of 76 days on the market, and sellers received an average of 92.2% of their original asking price. Inventory reached 6.2 months, according to Unlock MLS data reported by the Austin American-Statesman. In the same report, the City of Austin median held at $550,000 in October on 704 sales. Mortgage rates averaged 7.33% that month, up from 6.86% in September.
The top of the market has been moving faster than the rest. In July 2026, homes priced at $1 million or more averaged 58 days on the market, compared with 82 days for homes between $250,000 and $300,000, the Statesman reported. The paper noted that wealthier households are less exposed to financing costs.
These are metro averages, and they set the pace a Lost Creek buyer is shopping in. If you compare an older Lost Creek home against The Overlook, the useful match for the resale asking price is the finished price on a specific homesite, which for these five homes is about $878 to $1,047 per square foot. A $2.9 million plan starting price is the wrong match. Lost Creek's existing homes date to the early 1970s onward, on a subdivision that grew in a late-1970s and early-1980s building boom around a golf course and country club. That club was renamed Westlake Country Club in 2023, and it completed a multi-year clubhouse renovation in December 2025. An older Lost Creek house and a new one at The Overlook sit on the same hillside, and at The Overlook the homesite and what was built on it moved a single plan's price by $532,455.
A few quick answers
How large are the homesites at The Overlook? Community Impact reported lots ranging from 0.25 to 0.75 acre.
How many homes does the community have? Forty-eight homesites. The latest published count is 8 sold as of December 2025.
What size are the floor plans? MileStone's seven plans range from 3,326 square feet for the smallest Pinnacle to 5,257 square feet for the Destin.
The prices and rates above are general market information as of their dates, not financial advice. Confirm your own numbers with your lender and advisors. If you own in Lost Creek or elsewhere in Westlake and want to know where your home sits against a $4.6 million to $5.26 million new-construction sheet a few streets away, Walker Residential Group can run that comparison with you, starting with an instant home valuation.